DISPATCHES FROM THE EDUCATION APOCALYPSE: Nathan Cofnas and the violent cult of fragility.

The irony is too much: they accuse Cofnas of infantilising black people as a low-IQ population even as they infantilise black people as hyper-vulnerable individuals requiring official protection from thought, from words. Cofnas once infamously said that if universities ditched DEI and enforced a strict meritocracy, there’d be virtually no black academics. That’s grossly offensive, no doubt. Yet so is the idea that black kids at Oxford are such porcelain beings, so liable to be wounded by words, that the very thought of Cofnas being on campus is enough to propel them into a night of anguish. It’s the same idea, in fact. Cofnas says blacks aren’t clever enough for uni, his haters imply they lack the intellectual backbone for uni, which by definition involves exposure to difficult ideas. The bigotry of ‘low IQ’ vs the bigotry of low expectations.

On the cobbles of Oriel we saw how swiftly the cult of fragility can turn violent. How naturally the twin creeds of censoriousness and condescension lend themselves to physical-force bullying. Attendees of Cofnas’s talk were not only called ‘cunts’ – some were threatened and shoved into brick walls. Masked men prevented people from getting inside, hence the small audience of 40. Pro-Cofnas protesters were physically assaulted. Local cops say they’re investigating ‘multiple assaults’, including one against an officer.

Such thuggery is a natural outgrowth of the therapeutic mania of the modern campus. It is the violence of the Safe Space. For when you train an entire generation to conceive of words as weapons, and their fragile egos as the target, you inevitably nurture a culture of hair-trigger paranoia. Tell pampered young adults that a heterodox lecture is an act of physical aggression, and they will naturally treat the speaker like an armed intruder – not merely someone they disagree with but someone who poses a threat to their very psychic safety. Teaching the young to sacralise their emotional prestige above all else, and to view everything from ‘misgendering’ to ‘race realism’ as a dire threat to that prestige, was always going to whip up dread, hysteria and panicked menace.

At The Free Press, Douglas Murray adds: Race, IQ, and the Danger of Forbidden Knowledge.

The obvious thing for anyone who believes that people like Cofnas are wrong in their claims and research is to produce claims and research of their own. But the treatment of someone who was until recently a very obscure junior academic, and the unbelievable physical and institutional firepower aimed against him, is likely to have the opposite effect to that intended.

For what it is worth, my own observation of these debates is that much can be told by the way someone debates IQ differentials. If they survey them as the ethical and moral minefield they are, then they will discuss them in a spirit of interest and concern. If they describe their findings—accurate or otherwise—with glee, then you can be fairly sure they are engaged in another game. The only way to surmise the tone in which someone like Cofnas addresses these issues would be to hear him.

His opponents think they know what he is saying. In fact, they have simply closed themselves off from hearing him. In doing so, they have set up the conditions for many more people to listen to him. And the violence that greeted Cofnas on Tuesday suggests that much of his audience, present and future, will want more than some statistical evidence at their side. They will want to settle on the evidence and go to war with it. If they do, they will be able to claim, with some justification, that it is not a war they started.

Finally, from NRO’s Abigail Anthony: The Guardian’s Flawed Reporting on the Cofnas Event at Oxford University.

Cofnas added:

I explained why it was important. . . This is what DEI is, and DEI sets people up for failure. I’m curious if you asked the administrators of Cambridge who knew that he was a fraud in 2023. They knew he was a plagiarist, they knew he was a fabulist for three years. . . knowing that this could come out, and that he would be humiliated. And they chose to try to cover it up and intimidate people into silence. And they shut people down. It became an open secret at Cambridge that everyone was terrified to say.

I admittedly missed the next sentence because of the loud protesters; he said something to the effect of it only being a matter of time before someone found out about Arday’s misconduct and put it on social media.

“This was bound to happen,” he continued, addressing the reporter. “What’s their responsibility? What’s the responsibility of the people who then, after it became too much of an inconvenience for the university, they just threw him away? They said, you know, go home, you’re not protected. I would like them to receive these pointed questions.”

Cambridge is of course dodging those questions, and thus the responsibility for preventing another academic equivalent of Milli Vanilli from occurring.