Archive for 2014

ONE OF INSTAPUNDIT’S MANY READERS FROM THE INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY WRITES:

I don’t have a whole lot of institutional love for CIA, but I do feel the need to defend their honor on at least some point of what being misreported….

The first media reports and screaming headlines made it seem like CIA had sent wet-work teams to break into DiFi’s office to bug her computer, ala Watergate. Slowly the hysteria has been walked back, but some still persists. The Arstechnica headline for instance: “How CIA snooped on Senate Intel Committee’s files: It’s easy to search someone’s network when you hired the IT department.”

First, they weren’t SSCI’s files, they were CIA files in a CIA database that SSCI staffers were allowed access to. Additionally, it wasn’t “someone’s network” (i.e. SSCI’s), it was a CIA network that contained said database and files. So of course they hired the IT department. But if you read most of the press, you would think CIA was hacking Capitol Hill…

I highly recommend Eli Lake’s article from last Friday, for a balanced piece of reporting.

Now whether or not the monitoring/auditing done was normal innocuous IT activity, or the crime that DiFi seems to think it is, I have no idea. But I do know that most reporting has been based on speculation, misinterpretation, and projection, not actual facts. Like the ones Eli Lake was able to report.

On one last note, I am not sure how DiFi can claim that this is some grand 4th Amendment violation, given that the staffers are USG employees, doing USG work, on USG systems. Even if the activity was illegal, it in no way violated their personal expectations of privacy. Every USG computer system (and phone) is required to have disclaimers stating that their use implies a “Consent to be monitored”.

And given that post-Snowden NSA was roasted for not monitoring what files their own people could access, shouldn’t we applaud CIA to for perhaps tracking which files non-agency employees accessed?

Everything should generate an audit trail. It’s not clear that’s what happened here, though to be fair, it’s not clear it isn’t, though I believe DiFi and her staffers were promised that no one would track what they looked at, and that promise was broken. But — and this is my key point — while spying on foreigners is fine, trust in the intelligence community has taken a hit in no small part because so many other parts of the bureaucracy that are supposed to be apolitical have been politicized and weaponized by the Obama Administration. That kind of damage takes a generation to undo.

DESPERATION: Europe says US-made cheeses can’t use Old World names.

Errico Auricchio produced cheese with his family in Italy until he brought his trade to the United States more than 30 years ago. Now, the European Union is saying his cheese isn’t authentic enough to carry a European name.

As part of trade talks, the EU wants to ban the use of names like Parmesan, feta and Gorgonzola on cheese made in the United States. The argument is that the American-made cheeses are shadows of the original European varieties and cut into sales and identity of the European cheeses.

Meh. The real problem is the opposite: Like American beer-making, American cheesemaking has advanced to the point where it’s often superior to the European product. Blessed be the cheesemakers!

WOMEN ARE SUCH FRAGILE CREATURES, APPARENTLY, THAT THEY PROBABLY SHOULDN’T BE ALLOWED IN COLLEGE, OR OUT IN PUBLIC WITHOUT A MALE PROTECTOR: The Idiocy of “Trigger Warnings.”

PARASITE DEVOURS HOST: In San Jose, generous pensions for city workers come at expense of nearly all else.

Here in the wealthy heart of Silicon Valley, the roads are pocked with potholes, the libraries are closed three days a week and a slew of city recreation centers have been handed over to nonprofit groups. Taxes have gone up even as city services are in decline, and Mayor Chuck Reed is worried.

The source of Reed’s troubles: gold-plated pensions that guarantee retired city workers as much as 90 percent of their former salaries. Retirement costs are eating up nearly a quarter of the city’s budget, forcing Reed (D) to skimp on everything else.

“This is one of the dichotomies of California: I am cutting services to my low- and moderate-income people . . . to pay really generous benefits for public employees who make a good living and have an even better retirement,” he said in an interview in his office overlooking downtown.

In San Jose and across the nation, state and local officials are increasingly confronting a vision of startling injustice: Poor and middle-class taxpayers — who often have no retirement savings — are paying higher taxes so public employees can retire in relative comfort.

What, you thought public employee unionism was supposed to help the less fortunate?

21ST CENTURY RELATIONSHIPS: Pregnant mom who doesn’t want dad in the delivery room makes the rules, judge says. It’s not so much that I think this is unreasonable, as that I think if roles were reversed the judge would find some excuse to rule the other way, because it’s in the best interest of the child to have both parents present or something. Because men don’t have parental rights, just responsibilities.

A BEGINNER’S GUIDE to 3D Printing.

HIGHER EDUCATION BUBBLE UPDATE: Feminist Studies Professor Accused of Assaulting Teenage Prolife Demonstrator. “Much of the scuffle was recorded on a smartphone by the 16-year-old, Thrin Short. The yet-to-be-released video is now in the custody of Santa Barbara law enforcement officials, who are investigating the March 4 incident.” Well, stay tuned.

SHAKING UP THE CLASSROOM with competency-based learning.

U.S. K-12 education has been undergoing a revolution as states try new ways to boost graduation rates and better prepare students for college or work. Louisiana gives credit for classes offered by local businesses. Rhode Island allows students to earn “digital badges” outside the classroom for creating business plans. Students in Florida and Oregon take massively open online courses, or MOOCs, for high-school credit.

Competency-based learning goes further, jettisoning the century-old idea that students move ahead based on age and classroom time. In the past few years, Iowa, Connecticut, Maine and Utah changed laws to let districts define what a credit means, bringing the number to 29 states. . . .

But competency-based systems have critics. Ann Marie Banfield of the conservative group Cornerstone Action said she has taken calls from New Hampshire parents and teachers who complain the system, which the state mandated in 2005, is too focused on work skills, such as collaboration, and not enough on academic excellence. Others worry the setup focuses too heavily on testing and could allow some students who need prodding to move too sluggishly.

“There is appeal to moving students through the curriculum as they are ready,” said Daria Hall, director of K-12 policy at Education Trust, an advocacy group that focuses on closing the achievement gap. “But the risky downside is that it could translate into lower expectations in terms of how fast low-income and minority students are expected to progress.”

The question is whether the competency tests really test competency, or are just a different way to move kids along. The best solution is to let the tests come from outside.