MARK WHITTINGTON: Alien First Contact Paper Tainted By Media Misreporting. “The aliens commit genocide because we burn too much carbon comes right out of the odious remake of ‘The Day the Earth Stood Still.’ It is, however, unfortunate that this scenario, which is only one among many, is being played up. It plays into the meme, which has a certain grain of truth, that global warming hysterics are crazy. Now they are threatening us with alien invasion if we don’t change out evil, carbon burning ways.”
Meanwhile, Megan McArdle comments on the narrow-mindedness of those ETs. “It’s really remarkable, in fact, how often the aliens in science fiction just happen to be preoccupied with the exact same political issues that obsessed intellectuals of the era when the fiction was written. And yet it’s still somehow breathtaking. They don’t even notice that they’re not noticing all their embedded assumptions. For example, the scientists do not even consider the possibility that the recent decline in church attendance among the citizens of the world’s most powerful nations could be a signal to advanced, god-fearing aliens that we are a decadent and irreligious species who should be wiped out. . . . Of all the possibilities, the one that seems least likely to me is that advanced aliens capable of traveling between the stars will turn out to view global warming in very much the way that a handful of Western scientists do.”