Archive for 2006

DOMENECH ROUNDUP: Ben Domenech has apologized. Here’s a story from The New York Times, which quotes me accurately — but I should note that I added that the fact that people were out to get Domenech doesn’t get him off the hook. (Related thoughts here.)

Jeff Goldstein has further thoughts.

David M, meanwhile, takes the political temperature.

Also, Julian Sanchez makes the inevitable Army of Davids point: “The truth at the core of much often-tiresome blog triumphalism is precisely that the Post probably couldn’t have vetted anyone as effectively as a blogospheric swarm.”

And here’s a report on the ESPN plagiarism story, which seems to have been resolved.

UPDATE: A fairly depressing perspective from Ed Morrissey. And here’s another post about how it’s bad for the blogosphere: “Someone thinks they won here, but in the grand scheme, everyone will turn out the loser.”

And here’s a huge roundup from Joe Gandelman. On the other hand, not everyone thinks it’s a big story — it didn’t even get a mention on Slate’s “Today’s Blogs” feature.

ANOTHER CIVIL RIGHTS VICTORY:

After years of failed efforts, vetoes and political wrangling, Kansas will join most of the nation in allowing concealed weapons permits, starting this year.

The Kansas House voted Thursday to override Gov. Kathleen Sebelius’ veto of a concealed weapons bill, following a similar vote in the Senate on Wednesday. The action makes law a plan to allow citizens who pass a background check and training course to carry concealed weapons. The first applications can be filed July 1.
The House vote was 91-33, seven more votes than necessary to reject Sebelius’ veto.

“The people of Kansas have waited a long time for this,” said Sen. Phil Journey, a Haysville Republican who has worked for the bill for more than a decade, first as a citizen and then as a lawmaker.
Estimates are that 20,000 to 48,000 Kansans will apply for permits in the first four years. It will be up to Attorney General Phill Kline to work out rules for implementing the law, including whether Kansas will honor permits issued by other states.

Gun rights groups were ecstatic about crossing another state off the list of those that do not allow concealed weapons. Now, only three states have no right-to-carry law.

I hope that those backward states will catch up with the modern trend.

UPDATE: Jeff Soyer notes progress in Delaware, while some readers dispute the “three states” figure above, which does depend on definitions in a few cases. The trend, however, is indisputable.

EUGENE VOLOKH: “Trying to prevent people from being killed for their religious beliefs is not an ‘assault against Islam.’ It’s defense against Islam, or to be precise against a certain strand of Islam that regrettably cannot be dismissed as just some unimportant lunatic fringe.”

HEH: “President Chirac stormed out of the first session of a European Union summit dominated by a row over French nationalism because a fellow Frenchman insisted on speaking English.”

(Via Shannon Love, who observes: “Can You Imagine if Bush Did This?”)

UPDATE: Agnes Poirier defends Chirac: “the imperialism of the English language must be fought and will be fought to the bitter end.”

NEW PROBLEMS AT COLUMBIA, according to The American Thinker and a report in the New York Sun.

AFFIRMATIVE ACTION blowback?

BELARUS UPDATE:

Alexander Lukashenko, Belarus’ authoritarian president, was on Friday night facing coordinated sanctions from the European Union and US, hours after riot police wielding batons arrested 200 people staging a peaceful protest over Sunday’s disputed elections in the capital, Minsk.

EU leaders, at a summit in Brussels, and the White House both indicated they would impose visa bans on a wide range of senior officials from the former Soviet republic, including Mr Lukashenko himself. They also planned financial sanctions, such as freezes on bank accounts abroad. The tough EU and US response set them sharply at odds with Russia.

I don’t think it’s over yet.

THE CARNIVAL OF BAUER is up! So is the Carnival of Cars! [What kind of car does Jack Bauer drive? –ed. If I told you, I’d have to kill you.]

AN INTERESTING QUESTION about the war.

MARY KATHERINE HAM has pictures and a report from the Abdul Rahman rally that I mentioned earlier.

UPDATE: More pics from Tom Bridge.

ANOTHER UPDATE: Still more pics here. Meanwhile, a request for liberals to pay more attention to the case.

A REPORT OF ATF ABUSES IN EAST TENNESSEE.

UPDATE: Here’s a roundup on the story from the Knoxville News-Sentinel’s Michael Silence.

ANOTHER UPDATE: See the update here: It may have started as a dubious MG case, but apparently the later felon-in-possession charge is solid.

A BEN DOMENECH PLAGIARISM SCANDAL?

I’ve had my differences with Domenech in the past, but I hope there’s nothing to this. Some earlier writings of mine on plagiarism can be found here and here.

UPDATE: Here’s more from Howard Kurtz.

ANOTHER UPDATE: And from Michelle Malkin.

MORE: Still more here.

STILL MORE: Ben Domenech has resigned. I think they should replace him with Bill Hobbs — experienced journalist and blogger! Or maybe Bill Quick, though he’s not exactly Red.

Analysis here.

EVEN MORE: Bill Quick is honored to be nominated but doubts it would work out:

Good heavens! If the Kossacks et al hated Domenech, can you imagine how they would feel about me? Not to mention the Bush-bots and the committed religious? And the field day they’d have rooting through my years and years of writing on the net, not just on blogs, but in newsgroups and my published work?

The only way they could run me as a blogger would be as “The Blogger Who Pisses Everybody Off.” I doubt they are interested in that kind of thing.

Upside for Bill — it might improve sales of his past work!

Meanwhile, NewsAlert observes that all is not lost: “Still available to blog for the Washington Post are Doris Kearns Goodwin,Laurence Tribe,and Mike Barnicle.”

And Jon Henke comments on the underlying debate:

Ideological equality at newspapers? I don’t recall the Left being worked up about this before….. …but I’m very interested to see them pursue it at the New York Times, too!

Indeed. And Dave Price emails: “If not Bill Quick, why not Jeff Goldstein? The Left has already been about as abusive to him as they can be.” Yep. And it rolls right off. Plus, who could read Goldstein’s stuff and even imagine that it had been previously published?

FINALLY: Don Surber emails: “WaPo took your advice and tried to replace experienced, trained editorial writers and columnists with a blogger named Ben Domenech. Charges of racism and plagiarism immediately ensued.”

Well, I don’t think that argument flies — at least, the “experienced, trained” Nick Confessore embarrassed the New York Times this week, too. And it’s not like we haven’t seen plagiarism from “experienced, trained” journalists. More on the confluence of these two stories here.

And the last word — in this already-too-long post, anyway — goes to Patrick Hynes, who says it’s a story about the superiority of the new media over the old:

Interestingly, it was Ben Domenech’s writing in the Old Media that got him in trouble, not his blogging. So I will vociferously defend bloggers as a race when the Oldies say “Blogger was a plagiarist” and “Blogs have no credibility,” which is inevitable. . . .

This is, if you think about it, a story about the corruptibility of the Old Media anyway. Like I said before, blogging is about sincerity and authenticity – two things foreign to the Old Media. And attempts by the Old Media to fake sincerity and authenticity will fall flat. Every time.

Yes, those experienced, trained editors and fact-checkers missed the plagiarism that blog-readers caught.

OKAY, NOW THIS IS THE LAST WORD: Ben Domenech has posted a response to his critics.

MORE CRUSHING OF DISSENT: Evan Coyne Maloney was kicked off the Yale campus for asking Taliban-related questions. Lux et Veritas, indeed.

I HAVEN’T READ KEVIN PHILLIPS’ American Theocracy, which I saw piled up at my local bookstore the other day, but to paraphrase Tom Wolfe it seems that although theocracy is always descending on America, somehow it always lands in the Middle East. Even the Publisher’s Weekly review (follow the link to read it) says that Phillips overstates his case, but then adds something that is surely true: “Expect him to make some provocative appearances on chat shows.” And, to be fair, I’ve made a much milder version of this critique myself.

Rather than theocracy, however, I think that much of what’s often identified by pundits as religious sentiment in American politics has more to do with reaction against smug moralizing. As Mickey Kaus notes in response to a new poll on American attitudes toward gay marriage: “Americans may or may not like gay marriage, but they really hate having gay marriage crammed down their throat by self-righteous, unelected liberal judges! What the poll shows is that the gay marriage cause is only now finally recovering from the damage done to it by Anthony Lewis’ wife.”

There’s a book to be written on that phenomenon, I’m sure. Mickey?

IRANIAN NUKES: Don’t count on a Deus ex Tel Aviv.

AGGREGATING: Another Army of Davids review, this one at CBS Public Eye, and with this interesting passage:

While reading blogger Glenn Reynolds’s new book, “An Army of Davids: How Markets and Technology Empower Ordinary People to Beat Big Media, Big Government and Other Goliaths,” I was disappointed that he made only the briefest mention of the CBS scandal known as “Rathergate.”

Oh, well.

FREEDOM OF RELIGION IN AFGHANISTAN: Cam Edwards emails: “Not that you’re the Craigslist of rallies or anything, but I wanted to let you know that there’ll be a rally in support of Abdul Rahman outside the Afghan Embassy in Washington [today] at noon. The address is 2341 Wyoming Ave NW if you’d care to mention it.”

VICTOR DAVIS HANSON was rather hard on Time Baghdad bureau chief Michael Ware. Transcript and audio here.

MORE EMBARRASSMENT FOR YALE:

A statement from Yale University, defending its decision to admit former Taliban spokesman Ramatullah Hashemi, explained that he had “escaped the wreckage of Afghanistan.” To anyone who is aware of the Taliban’s barbaric treatment of the Afghan people, such words are offensive–as if Mr. Hashemi were not himself part of the wrecking crew. It is even more disturbing to learn that, while Mr. Hashemi sailed through Yale’s admissions process, the school turned down the opportunity to enroll women who really did escape the wreckage of Afghanistan.

In 2002, Yale received a letter from Paula Nirschel, the founder of the Initiative to Educate Afghan Women. The purpose of the organization, begun in that year, was to match young women in post-Taliban Afghanistan to U.S. colleges, where they could pursue a degree. Ms. Nirschel asked Yale if it wanted to award a spot in its next entering class to an Afghan woman. Yale declined.

Yale seems to have gotten itself into a PR quagmire.

THE ATLANTIC REVIEW looks at German media and asks: “Why is Abu Ghraib a cover story again, but not Darfur? . . . Why is the German media reporting again about the horrible Abu Ghraib pictures taken by dishonorable US soldiers, but not about the even more horrible Darfur pictures taken by an honorable former U.S. Marine?”

A “HUGE EXPLOSION” at a French college. Cause not yet known.

ED MORRISSEY:

The strategy adopted by Saddam Hussein for his trial on crimes against humanity that stem from his decades-long tyranny over Iraq has always been clear — he planned on diverting attention from the crimes and the evidence and focus the world on his political rants from the dock. He’s playing out the Goering strategy, unmindful of Goering’s failure with it. Unfortunately for us, the media has played into Saddam’s strategy, according to a study performed by the Media Research Center. After reviewing the coverage provided by the three American broadcast networks, MRC calculated that less than twenty percent of the news coverage reported on evidence, testimony, and the case background … when they could be bothered to cover the trial at all.

Imagine what things would be like if the news media actually sided with civilization.